MLS Cup Winner Odds: Who Should You Bet On?
This preview was written in May 2025, when the first quarter of the MLS season had been completed and the competition was taking shape. It was a new-look season, as teams looking to win the MLS Cup had to navigate breaks in the middle of the season for the FIFA Club World Cup and the CONCACAF Gold Cup.
Because of this, there was no league break for the Leagues Cup in late summer. Even so, there was no shortage of leading contenders for the title. Below is how the main ones looked at the time, and how each of their seasons ended. The 2025 MLS Cup has now been decided: Inter Miami beat the Vancouver Whitecaps 3-1 in the final on December 6, 2025.
Inter Miami
Unsurprisingly, the betting for the MLS Cup in 2025 was dominated by Inter Miami. The 2024 Supporters’ Shield winners had set an all-time record for the most points in a season, but they fell short of their target after losing their Round One series against Atlanta United.
Despite winning the first game in the series, Lionel Messi was powerless as he watched his side crash out of the playoffs. By May they already looked a much different team, having won six of their opening ten matches.
Their attack, led by Messi and Luis Suarez, had already scored 20 goals. The view at the time was that if they could keep their challenge going into the post-season, they would be difficult to beat in 2025.
That is how it played out. Miami went all the way and won the first MLS Cup in the club’s history, beating FC Cincinnati 4-0 in the Eastern Conference semi-finals on the way to the final. For future seasons, you can check how to bet on them here: youbet.com/soccer/best-mls-betting-sites/
Vancouver Whitecaps
Like Inter Miami, the Vancouver Whitecaps went out in the opening round of the 2024 playoffs, after beating the Portland Timbers in the Wild Card round. However, they looked like a team that had improved hugely during the off-season.
The Caps have enhanced their options in the final third, and the signings of Jayden Nelson and Emmanuel Sabbi gave them more threat going forward, even though they flew under the radar in the betting for the MLS Cup.
The early signs in 2025 were very bright, as they had won eight of their opening eleven matches in the Western Conference. As well as having the best attacking record in the West, they also had the best defensive record.
Vancouver went on to prove the early form was real. They beat FC Dallas in Round One, knocked out LAFC on penalties in the conference semi-finals and beat San Diego FC 3-1 to win the West, before losing 3-1 to Inter Miami in the MLS Cup final.
Columbus Crew
The Columbus Crew are typically overlooked in the MLS Cup betting, which is slightly surprising considering their excellent record in the playoffs. The team have won the competition three times, in 2008, 2020 and 2023, so twice since the start of the 2020 campaign.
Wilfried Nancy was hoping for more success after reaching the Leagues Cup final in 2024. The team were smart with their signings, bringing in players with MLS experience in the forms of Daniel Gazdag and Ibrahim Aliyu.
In May, the Crew were the standout team in the Eastern Conference after winning seven of their opening eleven matches. But they looked like they would need more from their attacking players as the season went on, as they had scored just 18 goals. Their playoff record made them hard to write off.
In the end, Columbus went out in Round One, losing a three-game series 2-1 to Ohio rivals FC Cincinnati.
FC Cincinnati
FC Cincinnati were also hoping for a deeper playoff run in 2025, after falling at the First Round hurdle in 2024 when they lost a three-game series against New York City FC.
They have improved year by year since entering MLS in 2019, but they had not gone further in the post-season than their run to the conference finals in 2023. The team had strengthened, though, which made them look better equipped to go deeper this time.
The addition of Kevin Denkey gave them a new option in the final third, while creative midfielder Evander was already one of the standout players in MLS. They had caught the eye by winning seven of their opening eleven matches. However, they needed to tighten up at the back after allowing 13 goals in that spell.
Cincinnati beat Columbus in Round One but were then thrashed 4-0 by Inter Miami in the conference semi-finals, so their wait for a first MLS Cup final goes on.
LAFC
The 2024 season didn’t end how LAFC had hoped, as their run was ended by a painful extra-time loss against the Seattle Sounders in the conference semi-finals.
However, the team’s record since joining the competition, especially in the playoffs, deserves huge respect. Going into 2025, LAFC had reached at least the conference semi-finals in each of the previous three seasons, and they had made the MLS Cup final in two of those three campaigns, winning it in 2022. The team strengthened again in the transfer window.
It took LAFC a bit of time to adjust following the departure of Carlos Vela, but they remained a team that knows what it takes to win big matches, which made them a dangerous opponent if they reached the playoffs in 2025.
They did, beating Austin FC in Round One, before a 2-2 draw with Vancouver in the conference semi-finals went to penalties and LAFC lost the shootout 4-3. The 2025 season is a reminder for anyone betting on future MLS Cups: early-season form is only a rough guide, and the playoffs can turn on one shootout, so bet with care.
You can try your MLS reads with play money by checking the free MLS odds on CentSports.
FAQ
How do MLS Cup futures bets work?
What is the Supporters' Shield?
Does winning the Supporters' Shield make a team the MLS Cup favorite?
Build a streak today
15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.
From Free Picks to Smart Plays: A 2026 Guide to Maximizing Value in Online BettingNovember 18, 2026
Nepal's Oman Series Has Changed Direction — and the Stakes Are Still HighNovember 9, 2026
How to Keep a Prediction Journal That Helps You Learn from Every ResultNovember 9, 2026