Three NFL Franchise Quarterbacks on the Trading Block This Offseason
Picture Kyler Murray on March 14th, refreshing X—formerly known as Twitter—in his Scottsdale mansion, watching Cardinals beat writers speculate about whether Arizona pulled the trigger before his $19.5 million cashes the day prior. Down in Atlanta, Kirk Cousins boxes up family photos from his locker while Michael Penix Jr. studiously examines his phone across the room, both men participating in the NFL's most uncomfortable ritual: the slow-motion divorce between franchise and failed savior. In Miami, Dolphins executives sit in conference rooms debating something unthinkable—whether Tua Tagovailoa is even insurable after three documented concussions, triggering a dramatic fall from grace since leading the league in throwing yards back in 2023.
The confetti has barely settled on Seattle's stunning victory against New England at Super Bowl LX in Santa Clara, the vaunted "Dark Side" defence suffocating MVP runner-up Drake Maye's every move en route to a dominant 29-13 victory and the Lombardi Trophy. But already, even though the Emerald City is still in party mode, the bookies are looking towards next season. The early NFL 2026 season online gambling odds currently make the newly minted champion Seahawks the +850 favorites to repeat as champions, but those relatively lengthy odds for a frontrunner suggest that next season's championship race is wide open.
But when the NFL returns to our screens in September, some teams could look much changed from how they did at the back end of last season. Two are already actively shopping their franchise QB, while another is considering allowing them to walk in free agency. And that's without even mentioning the wild Lamar Jackson to the Las Vegas Raiders rumors.
Kyler Murray's Arizona Adventure Surely Over
Arizona's expected to be frantically shopping Kyler Murray before March 15th, when $19.5 million of his 2027 salary becomes fully guaranteed—another balloon payment on a quarterback they mentally divorced from months ago. The former 2019 No. 1 overall pick managed just five starts in 2025 before a Week 5 foot injury shut him down. He posted 962 yards with six touchdowns and three interceptions before landing on IR, never returning despite December medical clearance, while the Cardinals rolled with Jacoby Brissett instead. That organizational vote of no confidence speaks volumes.
Across seven Arizona seasons, Murray has compiled 19,498 yards, 115 touchdowns, and a 67.1% completion percentage that looks respectable until you notice the zero in the playoff victories column. He'll turn 29 in training camp—theoretically prime years—but the market's treating him like damaged goods that teams wouldn't take if Arizona paid them. The Jets have assembled a package centered on their 2025 second-rounder plus a conditional 2027 first-rounder with performance escalators, but even that requires the Cardinals sweetening the pot with absorbed salary or additional picks.
What does it say about Murray's career that Arizona would rather eat $17.9 million in dead cap than keep him? The replacement plan's already in motion: Brissett continues as the starter for a year while hopefully snagging Ty Simpson in the second round of the draft. That seems astute business, providing they can find a new home for the soon-to-be former face of the franchise.
Tua Tagovailoa's Damaged Goods Too Much to Overlook
Miami's situation might be even bleaker. Tua Tagovailoa posted a disastrous 2-7 record as a starter in 2025, leading the entire NFL with 11 interceptions through nine weeks before getting benched for seventh-round rookie Quinn Ewers. The concussion history looms over everything like storm clouds: three documented incidents across five seasons, including the frightening Week 2, 2024 collision with Damar Hamlin that produced a fencing response visible from the upper deck. Did anyone expect this when the former Alabama Crimson Tide sensation was leading the entire NFL in throwing yards back in 2023, securing himself a mighty $212.4 million four-year extension in the process?
Tua's late-season performance after returning complicates the narrative—100.1 passer rating, 1,008 yards, and 10 touchdowns over his final five games suggest capability remains when healthy. "When healthy" is the operative phrase, isn't it?
His contract structure creates a March 15 deadline where $54 million guaranteed for 2026 meets an additional $3 million for 2027, boxing Miami into impossible choices. Cutting him triggers a $99.2 million dead cap nuclear bomb; even post-June 1 designation leaves $67.4 million (2026) plus $31.8 million (2027) scattered across two years. Trading provides the least-bad option at $45.2 million dead cap, and Miami's reportedly willing to absorb roughly $30 million to restructure everything into a one-year commitment for acquiring teams.
Miami is poised to give Ewers another chance under center, perhaps even bringing in Malik Willis for competition. But would anyone be brave—or stupid—enough to fork out a fortune to bring Tua into the building? It's certainly a big ask.
Kirk Cousins Atlanta Nightmare
Atlanta paid Kirk Cousins over $100 million, only to draft his replacement just weeks after paying him in the first place. That was a recipe for disaster from the get-go, and the Falcons were fully rewarded for their malpractice with an average 12-10 record across 22 starts, with 28 touchdowns against 21 interceptions.
In 2025, Cousins managed 10 points against a Miami defense surrendering 29.3 per game before getting benched. He posted 10 touchdowns and five interceptions across 10 games, a 37-year-old tumbling off the age cliff in real time.
January's contract restructure set up the divorce: Atlanta dropped his 2026 base salary to $2.1 million while preparing a post-June 1 release strategy that splits dead money across 2026-2027. The critical deadline hits on March 13th, when $67.9 million guaranteed for 2027 vests—money the Falcons absolutely won't pay. Cutting him saves only $2 million against 2026's cap, but provides $77.9 million relief for 2027, which is the actual prize.
Cousins "remained open" to returning to Atlanta, like someone who doesn't realize they're fired. Cleveland and Pittsburgh have surfaced as potential landing spots, though neither seems eager to inherit a 37-year-old whose career just cratered. The latter may well be the best option, but the veteran gunslinger will face a lengthy wait if he is to head to the Steel City. The Steelers have recently said they are willing to wait for Aaron Rodgers to make a retirement decision before pursuing other options, words that Cousins certainly wouldn't have wanted to hear as he bids to remain a starting QB in the NFL.
Track how these moves shift the market on our NFL odds page, and see who the public is backing in our NFL public betting numbers.
FAQ
What is dead cap?
What is a post-June 1 release?
Why do guarantee dates matter in trade talks?
How does a quarterback trade affect betting odds?
Build a streak today
15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.
NFL Thanksgiving 2026: 5 Matchups That Could Influence the Playoff RaceNovember 16, 2026
Late NFL Scores and the Point SpreadNovember 11, 2026
The NFL Opens With a Super Bowl Rematch, and Last Season Is a WarningAugust 17, 2026