NFL 2026: Which Quarterbacks Must Deliver from Week 1 Next Season
Many were surprised when the Giants traded back into the first round of the 2025 NFL draft to snag Jaxson Dart 25th overall. Even more were stunned when he ripped away former Super Bowl champion Russell Wilson's starting job by week four. And that wasn't the only quarterback stunner last season.
Kirk Cousins thought he was being handed the keys to the kingdom when he penned a $180 million deal with Atlanta two years ago. Then, the Falcons shockingly drafted Michael Penix Jr. eighth overall just a couple of weeks later. First Prime Time Kirk was the starter, then he wasn't, then he was again as he replaced the man that was brought in to replace him throughout the back end of last season.
And perhaps most notably, there was Kyler Murray. The former number one overall pick had chance after chance to finally deliver Arizona a successful season. He couldn't, and when he was downed with an injury last season, Jacoby Brissett claimed the starting berth for himself and never gave it back.
Heading into 2026, two quarterbacks carry that distinct kind of dread — not the routine uncertainty of a position battle, but the specific weight of men who cannot afford to be average for even three weeks. The league has already shown what happens when a coach's patience runs out. These two quarterbacks are about to find out just how short that leash really is.
Deshaun Watson - Cleveland Browns
Deshaun Watson's situation in Cleveland has become one of the most grotesque roster mistakes in NFL history. Three first-round picks were surrendered to Houston. A five-year, $230 million fully guaranteed contract that restructured the entire quarterback market. And the return? Nineteen games across three seasons. An NFL suspension that wiped out year one. A fractured shoulder in 2023. A torn Achilles in Week 7 of 2024. Then, in January 2025, that same Achilles re-ruptured — and Watson spent all of 2025 on the PUP list, watching from a distance while his franchise tried to figure out what it had done to itself.
His Cleveland numbers are: 1,148 passing yards, five touchdowns, and a 9-10 record. That's it. And yet the Browns can't release him without absorbing a dead-cap hit so catastrophic it would cripple the franchise for years. He's on the roster. The question is whether he's actually the quarterback.
Because here's what makes this situation truly unprecedented: Shedeur Sanders — a fifth-round pick, Day 3 of the NFL Draft — is a legitimate threat to his starting job. The former Colorado Buffalo sensation was projected as a top ten pick 12 months ago, only to slide all the way 144th overall and end up in the mortuary that is the Browns quarterback room. Then, he fought his way up from fourth on the depth chart, outlasting each of Joe Flacco, Kenny Pickett, and Dillon Gabriel to become Cleveland's starting QB by the end of the 2025 season.
Say what you want about Shedeur, but he's a fighter. No one can deny that. And next season, boy, will he fight Watson, tooth and nail. And his team needs him to, especially if the latest betting odds are to be believed. The latest odds from 5Gringos online sportsbook make the Browns the rank +1600 outsider to win the AFC North next season, and the team needs all the fight it can find.
The most expensive mistake in the NFL today is reportedly the front-runner to start Week 1. But when a fifth-rounder is "front-runner" conversation material at all, a vote of confidence isn't far away. How many more chances does a 30-year-old with two repaired Achilles actually get? If Watson stumbles early and Cleveland drops three of its first four, the noise around Sanders becomes impossible to ignore.
Tua Tagovailoa - Atlanta Falcons
The number that follows Tua Tagovailoa out of Miami is $99.2 million — the NFL-record dead-cap hit the Dolphins absorbed to release him this offseason. That figure tells you everything about how badly the franchise wanted to move on after his fourth documented concussion in 2024. The fifth-overall pick from Alabama, the 2023 Pro Bowler, the guy who once threw for 4,900 yards in a season — gone, cap casualty, set free at 28 with a history that makes every general manager in the league quietly nervous.
He landed in Atlanta on a one-year minimum deal. Not a prove-it contract with upside. Not a bridge deal with escalators. A minimum contract, the kind you give a backup audition, the kind that shouts "we believe in you about this much." New head coach Kevin Stefanski, president Matt Ryan, and GM Ian Cunningham have said publicly that Tua is "coming in to compete" with Michael Penix Jr., the third-year quarterback still recovering from a torn ACL. Open competition, the front office insists.
But here's what genuine open competition looks like when one player is on a minimum deal: Tua has to be so undeniably better that even the executives who didn't recruit him can't justify sitting him down. And then he has to stay healthy. And then he has to replicate that Miami form in a new system with a new coaching staff. One bad start, one exit after a hit, one whisper about durability from the training room — and the Falcons pivot to Penix without a moment's hesitation. There is no safety net here. This is prove-it-or-retire, playing out in front of a national audience.
Once Week 1 arrives, see how Cleveland and Atlanta grade out in our NFL expert picks and computer NFL picks.
FAQ
What is dead cap in the NFL?
Why can a backup quarterback win the job early in a season?
How do quarterback battles affect NFL betting?
What does +1600 mean for a division title?
Build a streak today
15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.
NFL Thanksgiving 2026: 5 Matchups That Could Influence the Playoff RaceNovember 16, 2026
Late NFL Scores and the Point SpreadNovember 11, 2026
The NFL Opens With a Super Bowl Rematch, and Last Season Is a WarningAugust 17, 2026