Sports Betting

Can McGregor Really Come Back After All This Time?

5 min read
Can McGregor Really Come Back After All This Time?

Conor McGregor hasn’t won a UFC fight since January 2020. However, his star power has remained sky high despite the ensuing losses and inactivity from fighting. 

“The Notorious” Conor McGregor is entering the octagon again — next month against Max Holloway at UFC 329. It marks his first fight in five whole years. For what it’s worth, the top-reviewed bookmakers all have McGregor as a big underdog against Holloway. 

You can guess why, right? Comebacks don’t usually go well, and that’s the exact territory McGregor finds himself in.

Speaking of which, most of the comeback discourses seems to focus on McGregor’s motivation. Is he still hungry after making hundreds of millions of dollars? Does he still love fighting? Is this guy even in a sound mind to fight again? 

We’re less interested in those questions, however. For us, the much more interesting storyline is whether his body is even ready to fight again?

Remember, McGregor isn’t coming back from just any layoff. He’s coming back from one of the nastiest UFC injuries we’ve seen in recent memory. McGregor’s comeback is almost unprecedented, as we get into next.

The Injury Was Worse Than Most Fans Remember

When people discuss McGregor’s absence, they usually lump everything together. The two losses to Dustin Poirier. The canceled fights. The steroid rumors. The sexual assault allegations and so on. It all starts feeling like one giant blur.

But let’s isolate the injury for a second. In his last UFC bout, his leg essentially snapped in half mid-fight. Who could forget Joe Rogan sitting down next to him in the cage because he couldn’t get up?

Conor McGregor’s last fight was stopped after one round when he snapped his leg. His post-fight interview with Joe Rogan became fodder for online memes. 

Modern medicine can do incredible things, and to McGregor’s credit, he appears to have recovered physically. Though this is where the steroid allegations stem from… but that’s a story for another article. 

For the purpose of this article, let’s just focus on him returning five years after the fact at the not-so-ripe age of 37 (and soon to be 38). Think about what made McGregor special in the first place. It was timing, distance management, and his striking ability to make opponents pay for even the smallest of mistakes. The dude was a true KO artist at his peak. 

But…those are exactly the skills that tend to fade during long layoffs. You can rebuild the body through rehab and training (and yes, illegal drugs). What you generally can’t get back as easily is speed and timing. There is simply no substitute for fighting at a consistent rate and keeping those skills steady. 

History also tells us the odds are staunchly against a comeback of this magnitude. Let’s take a look at similar comebacks in combat sports history. 

UFC Comebacks In Retrospect

McGregor will end up as a UFC all-time great. Without a doubt, for drawing power, but also in the ring (he won belts in two different weight classes, remember?). 

That’s why when guesstimating how he’ll fare in his return, it’s worth looking at other historical-level fighters in the same position. Here’s the history of it, with good and bad comeback examples:

Anderson Silva

Silva is probably the closest comparison McGregor has. He suffered a gruesome leg break against Chris Weidman in 2013, one that instantly became one of the most replayed injuries in combat sports history. To Silva’s credit, he returned just over a year later and kept fighting for nearly a decade afterward.

The problem is, he was never really Anderson Silva again. Before the injury, Silva was arguably the greatest fighter on the planet. Afterward, he went 1-7 with one no contest in UFC competition. He still had flashes of brilliance, but the dominance was gone.

Chris Weidman

Ironically, the man who benefited from Silva’s injury eventually suffered almost the same fate. Weidman’s leg snapped against Uriah Hall in 2021, creating one of the eeriest moments in UFC history. 

Like Silva, he fought his way back. And like Silva again, the in-ring results were never the same. Weidman managed just one victory after returning and looked noticeably slower and less explosive. That’s often the hidden cost of catastrophic injuries. Athletes can regain enough health to compete, but not enough to become the same athlete they once were.

Dominick Cruz

If McGregor wants a source of optimism, then look no further than Cruz. The former bantamweight champion spent years battling injuries that would’ve ended most careers. Multiple ACL tears. Multiple layoffs. Entire title reigns derailed by rehab.

Yet every time people wrote him off, he found a way back. Cruz eventually reclaimed the UFC title and remained competitive against elite opposition well into his late 30s. His career is proof that extraordinary athletes occasionally beat the odds.

George Foreman

No discussion of sports comebacks is complete without Foreman. He may be in a different combat sport than McGregor, but his story is one of a kind. 

After retiring in 1977, Foreman disappeared from boxing for a decade. When he returned, most people viewed him as a curiosity. He was older, heavier, and far removed from the terrifying knockout artist who fought Muhammad Ali.

Then he shocked the world. At age 45, Foreman knocked out Michael Moorer to become the heavyweight champion of the world. It’s still one of the most improbable achievements in sports history.

The reason we bring up Foreman is that he’s the exception everyone remembers. Unfortunately for McGregor, history is filled with far more Anderson Silvas than George Foremans. 

All this explains why McGregor is as big as a +300 underdog at most sportsbooks worth their own salt. It would probably be much higher if he weren’t so popular with casual bettors — bookmakers can’t risk a big loss and keep his odds at a “respectable” number in case a miracle happens.

Personally, we see no such miracle transpiring. This isn’t a Rocky movie, and McGregor truly is a shell of a shell of a shell of what he once was.

For more fight-night analysis before the next card, see our expert UFC picks.

FAQ

What does it mean when a fighter is a +300 underdog?
In American odds, +300 means a $100 bet would return $300 in profit if the fighter wins. Those odds imply roughly a 25% chance of winning before the bookmaker's margin is removed.
When was Conor McGregor's last fight?
His last fight was against Dustin Poirier at UFC 264 in July 2021, which ended after the first round when McGregor broke his leg. His last UFC win came against Donald Cerrone in January 2020.
Why do long layoffs matter so much in MMA betting?
Timing, reactions and distance management tend to fade without regular competition, and fighters often look rusty in their first bout back. Age and recovery from serious injury add to that uncertainty.
Does public popularity affect a fighter's odds?
It can. When lots of casual bettors back a star name, bookmakers may shorten that fighter's price to limit their exposure, which can make the popular side worse value than the true chances suggest.

Build a streak today

15 in a row = $100 · 21 in a row = $1,500 · Free to play.

Join free

More from Sports Betting